I’m currently in the middle of compiling a series of different blogs and articles which have made legitimate scientific, ethical criticism of WADA & McLaren report – some of which have made it into some mainstream media but not all.
The ethics of deciding to ban a Paralympic team based on that report with no further ‘evidence’ openly provided is appalling. How can someone who has had to fight & knows how hard it is to get sporting achievements be so blase about destroying clean athletes with a collective punishment.
It’s difficult enough in the UK – in certain sports at international level as the government has repeatedly cut funding for certain paralympic sports because it doesn’t fit their national policy. Over £35k needed and that doesn’t include any specific allowances for additional equipment or aids so that you can live a decent life. These allowances have also been repeatedly cut by the government in a relentless inhumane pattern of punishing vulnerable people so that they can reward elites.
Imagine in another country where living conditions are different too, how is not possible to work with another country to sort out infrastructure problems etc instead of making political statements that don’t do anything. As before re all the pointlessness of talking deterrents but not actually doing anything that is a deterrent. WADA lost that one years ago with it’s processes and allowances for some athletes & not others. There is no sensible message other than improving how things are done & if the agency or other sports organisations cannot achieve that by themselves, work with other regulators who can.
Out in the real world where people actually care about Russian health and don’t just talk about what it means for Putin (143million people and the media only talk about one), but what it might mean for clean paralympians in Russia who have made phenomenal efforts to get to compete on the international stage. What it means to their careers, their families who made sacrifices, their trainers and coaches who have encouraged them never to give up.
The only humane thing that can be done is to continue to fight back as an international community to ensure that these decisions can never be made again, to help other countries if we have something that may be of use or people who are useful to talk with, to get on and deal with issues quickly instead of stringing them out over multiple cycles. We owe it to all of us.
Gutted today. Hope to see Aaron competing again soon. Fantastic fighter.
I visited over the weekend – it didn’t really get going until today but they are running tai chi, taekwondo, hapkido, aikido, kungfu, broadsword sessions as a minimum and whatever else anyone who turns up wants to do.
This video has terrible sound quality but did ad hoc with my phone. However it contains rare ‘footage’ of Master Mark Worsfold from whom I’ve learnt taekwondo and also has been teaching taichi for over 30 years. He has a background of teaching martial arts including many years in the Army and has worked in theatre so combines both very well. He was diagnosed with Parkinson’s a number of years ago but still makes it look effortless. A truly great martial artist.
Prior to finding out about the Olympics, I think I had a mostly positive but limited opinion about Russia. I read Cancer Ward by Alexander Solzhenitsyn which was very moving and I was equally deeply moved by a video of his Harvard speech and an interview.
I was born and lived in the 70s to give some context, I have also lived in Turkey and was married to a Turkish man at one point for a number of years. I have read very little about Russia over the years. I remember commenting on a martial arts blog about Steven Seagal and Vladimir Putin but that’s about it. One of my martial arts instructors has lived and taught in Poland.
I have seen some fantastic, beautiful photos of natural scenery in Russia and heard from people who have visited and loved the warmth of people, the hospitality and friendliness – their eyes light up & they smile when they talk about their experiences and planning future trips.
So as I’ve tried to find out more incl context of Eastern Europe & Central Asia I’m really shocked and outraged again at what I have been reading in articles and social media. The appalling #Russiaphobia would have seemed unbelievable previously but sadly Brexit has shown in the UK that if you allow zenophobic messages to be delivered in multiple channels and formats then people say & do increasingly aggressive actions.
I am trying to figure out on Twitter for example who are bots or not, with computational propoganda on the rise, I will no doubt make mistakes.
I have been learning the Cyrillic alphabet via a really good app- Read Russian in 3 hours which does exactly what it says on the tin (albeit quite a lot of fast food references) and I have found a recent Russian newspaper to try and delve into. Am not really up to reading tweets or short posts yet as have not done the fundamentals of the actual grammar but can recognise odd words.
I have read some books about Russia / EE / Central Asia, in the middle of another and attended a talk at Pushkin House following a duckduckgo search on ‘cultural events in London’. I am somewhere to forming an opinion about the ‘British establishment’ view of Russia but not ready to be coherent – other than those of similar backgrounds who visit or live briefly in Russia and meet people briefly will form certain kinds of opinions. That could apply anywhere too.
I will continue to fit in learning Russian so that I can read Russian perspective rather than English language views / versions of views. I am also part way through reading about Russian healthcare – more on that another time.
I recently took my twin niece & nephew to Greenwich and did a rather inadequate job of explaining lines such as Meridian, longitude, latitude and how people’s assumptions can be based on where a group of people gathered / shared ideas at a certain point in time. We also had fun with finding different types of music from different countries on youtube. We went to the Maritime museum where they can run over the giant map upstairs and see that America and Russia are really neighbours ‘across the pond’ which is the Bering Sea.
Why should their imaginations be limited by prejudice?
I like others are furious at the treatment of Russian athletes before and during the Olympics. I first became aware of what was happening a couple of weeks before Brexit I think. As someone who helps coach young martial artists from time to time I am completely appalled at how the process has been handled. As principles – if you cheat it is an injustice to other athletes, if you call for/impose a punishment on clean atheletes it is an injustice. You cannot say to young people you can achieve anything you want if you train hard etc
It is good to see a Canadian starting to uncover more of the process and the report: https://marknesop.wordpress.com/2016/08/10/guilty-until-proven-guilty/
I have previously worked for a drug regulator (not in regulatory role but working in learning & development means you get to talk to different staff around the organisation) and have written some thoughts whilst I was blogless:
In short, technology is changing, drugs or other methods of substance delivery are changing, supply chains are changing and I don’t think a WADA can achieve what it is trying to do re enforcement and regulation. Whilst reading the report and other information about the sporting bodies – I am concerned about the lack of diversity of WADA, IAAF (headed by a British establishment Tory peer), IPC (headed by another Brit) executive & decision making representatives.
Political messages inflame expressions of hatred as evidenced by fans behaviour both on and offline at the Olympics. There is no point in putting Russia or other countries into some kind of political sin bin – it’s ridiculous – why not work with other regulators to actually put in place a realistic long-term deterrent if there is credible evidence but the hype and hastily assembled report makes assertions that it cannot back up (it looks like the author wants to dine out on it academically for a number of years). Russia can lead the way in anti-doping as an example to other countries.
I have been trying to follow bits of the Olympics and as a person interested in sporting achievements – whilst I support Britain (what a legend Mo Farah & others continue to be), it is brilliant to see clean Russian athletes great achievements – a lesson to all of us re indomitable spirit !